IJAFRS International Journal of African Studies 2710-4680 SvedbergOpen ijafrs-1-1-001 10.51483/IJAFRS.1.1.2021.1-13 Review Article Interrogating mainstream models of states and statehood in Africa: A critical review ChitongeHorman 1 * 1Centre for African Studies, University of Cape Town, South Africa. E-mail: horman.chitonge@uct.ac.za *Corresponding author: Horman Chitonge, Centre for African Studies, University of Cape Town, South Africa. E-mail: horman.chitonge@uct.ac.za 03 2021 1 1 1 13 Abstract

Scholarship on ‘states in Africa’ has been evolving into a distinct field of study, with a remarkable growth of literature occurring during the 1980s and the 1990s. This growth, however, is no mere coincidence; it occurred at a time when states in Africa were widely believed to have degenerated into a condition of irredeemable decay, and the large body of literature produced was meant to diagnose the malaise. The growing incidences of insurgences in different parts of Africa are raising similar questions about the notion of statehood in Africa. This paper provides a critical review of the conceptual approaches adopted in the mainstream scholarship on states and statehood in Africa. The paper concludes that understanding statehood in Africa requires paying attention to the different political formations which shape the character of states rather than applying the ideal-type models.

 Keywords State formation African states Statehood Political contestation Political formations References AdetulaVictor. (2011). Measuring Democracy and ‘Good Governance’ in Africa: A Critique of Assumptions and Methods. K.KondloC.Ejiogu (eds.) Governance in the 21st Century. Pretoria. Human and Social Sciences Research Council. 10–25. AhluwaliaPal. (2001). Politics and Post-colonial Theory: African Inflections. London: Routledge AkudeJohn. (2007). The failure and collapse of African states: On the example of Nigeria. FRIDE Comment, Lagos: FRIDE September 2007. AlaviHamza. (1972). “The state in post-colonial societies—Pakistan and Bangladesh. New Left Review, 74 (July-August). 59–81. BarnettMichael. (2002). Historical sociology and constructivism: An estranged past, a federated future,” in Historical Sociology of International Relations, S.HobdenJ.M.Hobson(eds.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 105–127. ChabalPatrick.DalozJean-Paul. (1999). Africa Works: Disorder as Political Instrument. London: James Currey. ChitongeH. (2015). Economic Growth and Development in Africa: Understanding Trends and Prospects. London/New York: Routledge CilliersJakkie.SiskTimothy. (2013). Assessing Long-term State Fragility in Africa. Pretoria: Institute for Security Studies. ClaphanChristopher. (2001). Rethinking African states. African Security Review. 10(3). 6–16. CrockerChester. (2019). African governance: challenges and their implications. Hoover Institution Winter Series, Issue 119. Monday 14 January. de OliveiraRicardo-SoaresVerhoevenHarry. (2018). Taming interventions: sovereignty, statehood and political order in Africa. Global Politics and Strategy. 60(2), 7–32. DoornbosMartin. (1990). The African state in academic debate: retrospect and prospect. Journal of Modern African Studies, 28(2), 179–198. DoornbosMartin. (2015). Conceptualizing African statehood and legitimacy: Shifting positions in the research-politics nexus,” in Social Research and Policy in the Development Arena. EADI Global Development Series. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 44–66. DormanSara. (2009). Patrick chabal: An appreciation?. Critical African Studies, (2), 10–18. EcksteinHarry. (1979). On the Science of the States. Deadalus, 108(4), 1–20. EkehPeter. (1975). Colonialism and the two publics in africa: a theoretical statement. Comparative Studies in Society and History, 17(1), 91–112. FirstR. (1970). The Barrel of the Gun: Political Power in Africa and the Coup d’Etat. London : Penguin Press. FortesMeyer.Evan-PritchardE.E. (1940[1970]). Introduction. in African Political Systems, in M.Fotes & E.Evans-Prichard (eds.). London: Oxford University Press. 1–24. GeertzClifford. (1977). The judging of nations: some comments on the assessment of regimes in the new states. European Journal of Sociology, 18(2), 249–61. HerbstJeffrey. (1996). Responding to State Failure in Africa. International Security, 21(3), 120–144. HerbstJeffrey. (2000). States and Power in Africa: Comparative Lessons in Authority and Control. Princeton: Princeton University Press. HillJonathan. (2005). Beyond the other? a postcolonial critique of the failed state thesis. African Identities, 3(2), 139–154. HydenGoran. (1980). Beyond Ujamaa in Tanzania: Underdevelopment and Uncaptured Peasantry. London: Heineman. JacksonRobert.RosbergC. (1982). Why Africa’s weak states persist: the empirical and juridical in statehood. World Politics, 35(1), 1–24. JacksonRobert. (1990). Quasi-States: Sovereignty, International Relations and the Third World. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. KaplanD. Robert. (1994). The coming anarchy: how scarcity, crime, overpopulation, tribalism, and disease are rapidly destroying the social fabric of our planet. Atlantic Monthly. 273(2), 44–76. LarmerMiles.M.HinfelaarB.PhiriL.SchumakerM.Szeftel. (2014). Introduction: Narratives of nationhood. Journal of Southern African Studies, 40(5), 895–905. LewisDavid. (2001). Civil society in african contexts: reflections on the usefulness of a concept. Development and Change, 33(4), 569–586. LeysColin. (1976). The ‘overdeveloped’ post-colonial state: a re-evaluation. Review of African Political Economy, (5), 39–48. MafejeArchie. (1971). The ideology of tribalism. Journal of Modern African Studies. 9(2), 253–261. MamdaniMahmood. (1996). Citizen and Subject: Contemporary Africa and the legacy of Late Colonialism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. MazruiAli. (1994). Decaying parts of africa need benign colonization. International Herald Tribune. Pretoria, 4 August. MkandawireThandika. (2001). Thinking about the developmental states in Africa. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 25(3), 289–313. NabudereDani. (2006). Development theories, knowledge production and emancipatory practice. in The Development Decade? Economic and Social Change in South Africa 1994-2004, V.Padayache (ed.). Pretoria: HSRC Press. 33–52. NeimannMichael. (2007). War making and state making in central Africa. Africa Today, 53(3), 21–39. NettlP. J. (1968). The state as a conceptual variable. World Politics. 20(4), 559–592. NeubertDieter. (2012). Civil societies in Africa? forms of social self-organisation and local socio-political order. Bayreuth African Studies Working Paper 12. NtsebezaLungisile. (2006). Democracy Compromised: Chief and the Politics of Land in South Africa. Cape Town: HSRC. NugentPaul. (2010). States and social contracts in Africa. . New Left Review. 63, May-June 2010. 35–68. Press. OlukoshiAdebayo.LaaksoL. (1996). The crisis of the post-colonial nation-state project in Africa. in A.Olukoshi. and L.Laakso (eds.) Challenges of the Nation-State in Africa. Uppsala: Nordic Africa Institute. PrattC. (1968). The Critical Phase in Tanzania 1945-1968: Nyerere and the Emergence of the Socialist Strategy. New York: Cambridge University Press. RivkinAnold. (1969). Nation-Building in Africa: Problems and Prospects, New Brunswick: Rutgers RotbergRobert. (2013). Africa Emerges: Consummate Challenges, Abundant Opportunities. Cambridge: Polity. RotbergRobert. (1966). African nationalism: Concept or confusion?. Journal of Modern African Studies, 4, 133–146. SangmpamS. N. (1993). Neither soft nor dead: the african state is alive and well. African Studies Review, 36(2), 73–94. ShuriyeAbdiAjalaMosud. (2016). The future of statehood in Africa. Journal of Sustainable Development, 9(2). 221–229. StarkF. (1986). Theories of Contemporary State Formation in Africa: A Reassessment. Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol. 24, No. 2. 335–347. United Nations Economic Commission for Africa (UNECA). (2009). African Governance Report (AGR II). New York: Oxford University Press.